On this page
- A trustee who holds the power to sell needs neither a court order nor the beneficiaries' approval, unless the trust instrument makes someone's consent a condition.
- The trustee's duties still govern the sale, and Probate Code section 16060 requires keeping the beneficiaries reasonably informed.
- A beneficiary who objects can go to court under section 17200 or section 16420, and an injunction before closing is worth more than a claim after it, because a good-faith buyer is protected.
- Written consent protects the trustee only against the beneficiary who gave it, and only within the limits of section 16463.
- A notice of proposed action, or a petition for instructions, can settle the question before the building is sold.
Yes. A California trustee who holds the power to sell can sell a trust building without the beneficiaries' approval, unless the trust instrument makes someone's consent a condition of the sale. The beneficiaries still have rights in the sale, though. They are owed information about it, the sale has to meet the trustee's duties, and a beneficiary who believes it does not can ask a court to stop it or to hold the trustee to account afterward.
Where does the power to sell without approval come from?
It comes from the trust instrument and from the Probate Code. Section 16226 gives a trustee the power to dispose of property at public or private sale, and section 16200 lets a trustee use the powers in the instrument, and the statutory powers the instrument does not limit, without court authorization. Neither section conditions the power on a vote of the beneficiaries.
The instrument can add that condition, and when it does, the condition is part of the power. A clause might require the written consent of a majority of the beneficiaries before any real property is sold, or the consent of a named person, or it might leave the building to one beneficiary outright. Read the powers clause and every amendment before the listing is signed. If a consent requirement applies, get the consents in the form the clause describes, because the title company may ask for the excerpt that gives you the power to act in this sale.
What still binds a trustee who sells without consent?
The same duties apply to it as to every other decision a trustee makes. Section 16202 makes the exercise of any power subject to the trustee's fiduciary duties, so the price, the buyer and the timing have to satisfy the duties of loyalty, impartiality and prudence whether or not anyone signed off on them.
Selling without consent is also a different thing from selling without telling anyone. Section 16060 requires you to keep the beneficiaries reasonably informed of the trust and its administration. A beneficiary who first hears of the sale from the buyer's inspector has a grievance before any question of price comes up. Tell them the building will be sold and why, what the evidence of value shows, and when the listing starts, and send the offers you are weighing as they arrive.
What can a beneficiary who objects do?
Unless the trust makes an objection a veto, it stops nothing by itself, so a beneficiary who wants the sale stopped has to ask the court. Section 17200 lets a beneficiary petition about the trust's internal affairs, which include passing upon the acts of the trustee and instructing the trustee. Where the trustee has committed a breach of trust or threatens to, section 16420 lists what the court can order.
| What the beneficiary wants | What section 16420 lets the court do |
|---|---|
| To stop a sale that has not closed | Enjoin the trustee from committing the breach, compel the trustee to perform the trustee's duties, or appoint a receiver or temporary trustee. |
| To hold the trustee to account | Compel the trustee to redress the breach by payment of money or otherwise, reduce or deny the trustee's compensation, or remove the trustee. |
| To reach the property or its proceeds | Set aside the trustee's acts, impose an equitable lien or a constructive trust, or trace and recover trust property, in each case subject to section 18100. |
The words "subject to section 18100" carry the most weight once the deed has recorded. That section protects a buyer who dealt with the trustee in good faith, for value, and without actual knowledge that the trustee was exceeding or improperly exercising a power, as if the power were being properly used. Against a buyer like that, the remedies that matter are the ones against the trustee. A beneficiary's time to act is therefore before closing, and a trustee who receives an objection should answer it promptly and in writing.
How does a beneficiary's written consent affect your liability?
Consent protects you as to the beneficiary who gives it. Under section 16463, a beneficiary who consented before or at the time of an act cannot later hold the trustee liable for it as a breach of trust. The same section lists when consent fails:
- The beneficiary was under an incapacity when consenting.
- The beneficiary did not know of his or her rights and of the material facts that the trustee knew or reasonably should have known, and that the trustee did not reasonably believe the beneficiary knew.
- Improper conduct by the trustee induced the consent.
- Where the trustee's interest in the transaction is adverse to the beneficiary's, the transaction was not fair and reasonable to that beneficiary.
A consent is worth what the beneficiary knew when signing, so send the valuation, the offers and the proposed terms with the consent form, and have it signed and dated before closing. It also binds only its signer. If three of four beneficiaries sign, the fourth keeps every claim the section 16463 defense would have answered.
Can you settle the question before the sale closes?
You can, in either of these ways, and each works better started early. The first is a notice of proposed action under Probate Code sections 16500 to 16504. It is available for a matter governed by the chapter of the code that holds the trustee's powers, which includes the power to sell. The notice names the trustee and a contact, describes the proposed sale and the reasons for it, and gives at least 45 days from mailing for objections. A beneficiary objects by mailing a written objection to the address in the notice within that time. If none arrives from a beneficiary, you are not liable to that beneficiary for the action, and if no beneficiary entitled to notice objects, you are not liable to any current or future beneficiary for it.
The second is a petition asking the court for instructions under section 17200 before you sign a contract. It suits the sale an objection has already made contentious, or one in which you or a relative would be the buyer. Plan the calendar around either route. A notice's objection period can run while the building is being marketed, and the contract's closing date can be set to fall after it ends.
Drafting the notice or the petition is legal work, and Shaya holds a real estate license and no law license, so the trust's attorney should prepare either one. The evidence that goes with it is where Shaya comes in: a written opinion of value from the rent roll and nearby sales, and the offers the building has drawn, set out in a form the attorney can attach.