On this page
- Does every co-trustee have to agree to the sale?
- What if an office is vacant, or a co-trustee cannot act for now?
- Can one co-trustee handle the sale for all of you?
- Are you liable for a co-trustee's breach?
- What will escrow and title need from each trustee?
- Agree in writing before the building is listed
- What happens when co-trustees deadlock?
- Probate Code section 15620 lets co-trustees exercise a power only by unanimous action unless the trust says otherwise, so every acting trustee agrees to the sale and signs for it.
- If an office is vacant, the remaining co-trustees may act alone. If a co-trustee is only temporarily unavailable, the others may act only where it is necessary for the trust's purposes or to avoid irreparable injury to its property.
- No trustee may hand the entire administration to a co-trustee, and each must take reasonable steps to stop a co-trustee's breach.
- When co-trustees cannot agree, a petition under section 17200 can ask the court for instructions.
Two or more trustees who hold a building together have to sell it together. Unless the trust instrument lets fewer of them act, Probate Code section 15620 requires co-trustees to exercise the power to sell by unanimous action, so each acting trustee agrees to the sale and signs the documents that carry it out.
The exceptions are narrow. Learn them before the building goes on the market, since every stage of the sale needs the signatures.
Does every co-trustee have to agree to the sale?
Yes, unless the trust says otherwise. Section 15620 lets a power held by two or more trustees be exercised only by their unanimous action, and selling calls on that power again and again: at the listing agreement, each counteroffer, the purchase contract, the escrow instructions and the grant deed. If three siblings hold the office together, a counteroffer signed by two of them is not unanimous action. All three sign.
Read the instrument for anything that changes the rule. It may let any one trustee act alone, let a majority act, give one trustee charge of real property, or say how a disagreement is to be settled. Whatever it provides, the certification of trust can state it for the title company, since section 18100.5 lets a certification say whether all of the trustees or fewer than all must sign.
What if an office is vacant, or a co-trustee cannot act for now?
The Probate Code treats these situations differently. Where an office is vacant, as it is when a co-trustee has died, section 15621 lets the remaining co-trustees act for the trust as if they were the only trustees, unless the trust instrument provides otherwise. Check the instrument before relying on that. It may name a replacement, who has to accept the office and then sign with you. Put the death on the record with an affidavit of death of trustee, and have the trustees who remain sign a new certification.
A co-trustee who is only temporarily unavailable, because of absence, illness or another temporary incapacity, is a narrower case. Section 15622 lets the others act as if they were the only trustees where that is necessary to accomplish the purposes of the trust or to avoid irreparable injury to the trust property, again unless the instrument provides otherwise. A burst pipe or a lapsing insurance policy fits those words more easily than a sale does. Before anyone signs a listing or a contract without the absent trustee, ask the attorney whether the test is met, and ask the title company whether it will insure a deed signed that way.
A long trip is a scheduling problem more than a legal one. Agree on how documents will reach the traveling trustee for signature and notarization before the listing goes live.
Can one co-trustee handle the sale for all of you?
One of you can carry the work, within limits the Probate Code sets. Under section 16012, a trustee may not delegate the entire administration of the trust to a co-trustee, or delegate acts the trustee can reasonably be required to perform personally. When a matter is properly delegated to a co-trustee, the trustee who delegated it keeps a duty of general supervision. Section 16013 adds that each trustee must participate in administering the trust and take reasonable steps to prevent a co-trustee's breach, or to compel a co-trustee to redress one.
In a sale, that leaves room for one co-trustee to be the contact for the broker and escrow, gather the leases and the rent roll, and schedule showings. The decisions that belong to the trust, which are the price you will accept, the buyer and the terms, stay with all of you, and the file should show that each of you saw each offer.
Are you liable for a co-trustee's breach?
As a starting point you are not, but the exceptions reach a trustee who stands aside. Section 16402 says a trustee is not liable to the beneficiary for a breach of trust committed by a co-trustee, and then makes a trustee liable in these circumstances:
- You participate in the co-trustee's breach.
- You improperly delegate the administration of the trust to that co-trustee.
- You approve, knowingly acquiesce in, or conceal the breach.
- You negligently enable the co-trustee to commit it.
- You neglect to take reasonable steps to compel the co-trustee to redress a breach you knew about, or had information that should have told you about.
Read with the duty to participate, the rule gives no cover to a co-trustee who signs whatever arrives or stops reading the offers. Object in writing to a sale to a co-trustee's relative at a price nobody tested, and copy the trust's attorney. The duties that govern a trustee's sale set the standard you would be measured against. Under section 16420, a co-trustee as well as a beneficiary can ask the court to enjoin a threatened breach.
What will escrow and title need from each trustee?
The buyer's title insurer is being asked to insure that the people signing the deed hold the power to convey the building, so from co-trustees it looks for these:
- A certification of trust under section 18100.5, signed by all of the currently acting trustees as an acknowledged declaration.
- If title asks, the excerpts of the trust that name the current trustees and give them the power to act in this sale, which the statute lets it require.
- Each trustee's signature on the grant deed, acknowledged before a notary, as the Registrar-Recorder's recording requirements call for.
- Where a co-trustee has died, the recorded affidavit of death of trustee.
- Where the trust lets fewer than all of you act, the clause that says so.
Escrow also needs every acting trustee on the escrow instructions and the closing documents, because the trustees together are the seller.
Agree in writing before the building is listed
Disagreements among co-trustees are cheaper to settle before an offer arrives than after one does. Before you sign a listing agreement, put these points in a short memorandum that every co-trustee signs:
- The broker you will list with, and which trustee is the broker's contact.
- The lowest price the trustees will accept without meeting again, and the evidence behind it, such as an appraisal or a written opinion of value.
- How an offer is accepted or countered, and how quickly each trustee will respond, so a buyer is not left waiting on one signature.
- Who signs what, and where each trustee will be when escrow closes, so the notarized signatures can be scheduled.
- Who reports to the beneficiaries and when, since section 16060 requires keeping them reasonably informed.
The memorandum changes nothing in the trust and relieves no one of a duty. What it gives you is a record of what each trustee agreed to, which is what a beneficiary or a court will ask about later. Shaya can send every co-trustee the same opinion of value and the same copy of each offer at the same time, so no one trustee holds information the others lack.
What happens when co-trustees deadlock?
If the trust gives no tie-breaker and you cannot agree, the trust cannot sell, because the unanimous action section 15620 requires is missing. The way forward runs through the court. Under section 17200, a trustee may petition concerning the trust's internal affairs, and those include instructing the trustee. A co-trustee who believes the other is breaching a duty, for instance by refusing a sound offer for personal reasons, can also seek the section 16420 remedies, which include compelling the trustee to perform and removing the trustee.
A petition takes time and costs fees, and the building has to be run while it is pending. Whether your disagreement calls for instructions or for a breach claim is a legal question for the trust's attorney. Shaya is a real estate agent and gives no legal advice, but he can supply evidence that bears on it, in the offers buyers have made.